Gary's Story The Project Seeking Clemency Gary's Advocates Contact Donate
Seeking Clemency · Florida, 2026

The question isn't whether it's safe to release him.It's what reason remains for keeping him.

Criminologists call the study of how people leave criminal behavior behind desistance. Decades of research converge on a small number of factors that reliably predict whether a formerly incarcerated person will return to crime. Gary Farrington meets every one of them — and has for eighteen years.

II.
Why This Is The Only Path

Florida offers no other mechanism.

Florida abolished parole for crimes committed after October 1, 1983, and eliminated it entirely for all crimes in 1994. There are now more than 10,900 people serving Life Without Parole in Florida. None of them has any statutory path to release, regardless of what the record shows.

For Gary, executive clemency — the Governor, together with at least two of three Cabinet members, voting to commute his sentence — is the only legal mechanism available. There is no other door.

Clemency is not a pardon. It does not erase the crime. It does not expunge the conviction. It recognizes that a sentence handed down to a nineteen-year-old in 2003 is not the only instrument the state can use in 2026, after eighteen years of documented transformation that the law provides no way to formally review.

The Process in Florida

Three stages. One very narrow door.

1

Application Filed

Formal application submitted to the Florida Commission on Offender Review (FCOR).

2

Investigation & Report

FCOR investigates conduct, programming, risk factors, and victim input; produces a report for the Clemency Board.

3

Quarterly Board Hearing

Governor + at least 2 of 3 Cabinet members must vote yes.

III.
The Evidence Base

The Seven Predictors of Desistance

The criminological literature on desistance — the process by which formerly offending individuals stop offending — converges on a consistent set of factors that predict successful reentry.

What follows is Gary's record tested against each one. The verdict, in every case, is the same.

Where this evidence would be heard.
No.
Predictor
Gary's record
Verdict
1

Age at release (40+)

Criminal activity peaks between 18 and 24 and declines sharply thereafter. BJS: age is among the strongest single predictors of reduced reoffending.

Gary is in his early 40s. He was 19 at the time of the crime. Decades past the peak-risk bracket.

Match
2

Time served with documented good conduct

Sustained institutional conduct over long time horizons is a strong predictor of post-release behavior.

Eighteen consecutive years without a single disciplinary infraction, beginning November 30, 2007. Among the longest clean records of any life-sentenced inmate in Florida.

Match
3

Educational attainment

Post-secondary education earned during incarceration correlates strongly with reduced recidivism (RAND).

Two post-secondary degrees earned inside: Associate of Theology (Logos, 2016) and B.A. Christian Ministry (NOBTS, 2018). Ordained minister. Florida DOC-approved Field Minister.

Match
4

Prosocial identity transformation

Lasting change involves an identity shift — the person understands themselves as fundamentally different from who they were.

Founder and pastor of Kings Highway Church at Hamilton CI. Head mentor of the Second Chance Faith & Character Academy. Teacher of the FDC-recognized DIRECT cognitive behavioral therapy program.

Match
5

Strong social bonds

Formerly incarcerated people with stable, pro-social relationships return to prison at significantly lower rates.

Twenty-plus-year support network (the Wollens as de facto family). Mitchell reconciled through Malachi Dads and has stayed free. Mother reconciled before her passing.

Match
6

Accountability and victim awareness

Genuine, sustained accountability — not strategic remorse — predicts better post-release outcomes.

Full accountability over 22+ years. Letter of Remorse on file with the Nuvolone family. Gary uses his own crime as the DIRECT case study every session. Future foundation named for his victim.

Match
7

A concrete reentry plan

People who return with a specific structured plan reoffend at significantly lower rates than those released without one.

Detailed reentry vision centered on Jacksonville, FL. Specific transition programs identified. Explicit commitment to continue ministry outside and work with at-risk youth.

Match
IV.
Voices from Inside · The Archive

The strongest testimony comes from the men in the next bunk.

Between June and November 2024, fifty-four men incarcerated alongside Gary at Hamilton Correctional Institution wrote handwritten letters on his behalf. A small selection follows, attributed by initials.

Handwritten letter of support from K.H., page 1 of 3
K.H. · Handwritten · Page 1 of 3 Hamilton SSCI · 2024
K.H. · Second Chance Faith & Character Dorm · Hamilton SSCI

“I have not met an individual, incarcerated or not, who devotes themselves more fully.”

On Monday and Friday afternoons from 4:00–5:00 PM, I attend and participate in DIRECT along with around 35 to 40 other guys in the dorm. Gary selflessly volunteers his time each week to prepare for and facilitate the class. He does an amazing job teaching all of us how to recognize and identify 65 different criminal thinking patterns and errors.

My favorite and most looked-forward-to day of the week here at Hamilton SSCI is without a doubt Wednesday. Every Wednesday afternoon at 4:00 PM we hear Gary preach the Word of God at Kings Highway Church. Even though the capacity in the sanctuary is approximately 120, on several occasions we have had to open the partition that divides the sanctuary with a large classroom, just to be able to accommodate seating.

If granted clemency, the beneficial impact that Gary would make on society is incalculable and immeasurable.

Handwritten letter of support from M.M.T., page 1
M.M.T. · Handwritten · Page 1 of 3 Hamilton SSCI · 2024
M.M.T. · 51 years old · Four-time TBI survivor · Hamilton SSCI

“For the first time in forty years, I feel safe and free from harm.”

I am a four-time traumatic brain and spinal cord injury survivor with neurological disorders. Fully disabled due to the number of debilitating conditions I suffer from on a daily basis. I am an epileptic suffering a constant barrage of seizures.

For someone like me, with special needs and disabilities, Mr. Gary set a brand-new standard, giving me life skills and transitional life skills, faith-based services within a harassment-free, abuse-free environment. Honestly, what Mr. Gary has done ought to be studied closer and implemented on every short-sentence correctional institution.

Here at fifty-one years of age, with this beautifully hearted man, I feel safe and free from harm. Healed people heal other people. I hope and pray you also see him for who he is today.

Handwritten letter of support from N.M.P., page 1
N.M.P. · Handwritten · Page 1 of 2 Hamilton SSCI · 2024
N.M.P. · Doctor of Pharmacy · Hamilton SSCI

“I can testify to his transformed life in Christ.”

Through an unexpected turn of events, I find myself writing from Hamilton Short Sentence Correctional Institution, where in the Providence of God I have had the pleasure of meeting Mr. Gary Farrington, Field Minister approved by the Department of Corrections.

His transformed life has been validated by those who initially recommended him for admission to a seminary program from NOBTS, from which he graduated with a Bachelors in Christian Ministry. His ministry has also been validated at Hamilton SSCI where he has earned the respect and trust of many officers and staff.

Gary does an outstanding job of teaching the Cognitive Behavioral Therapy class named DIRECT. Combining this knowledge with his theological training, he is able to offer real hope for change and transformation as the changes needed at the deep-rooted issues of the heart, which he has already dealt with.

+51
More voices in the archive

Fifty-four letters. Ninety-three pages. Transcribed verbatim.

What follows are shorter excerpts from the remaining archive — each a different dimension of Gary's daily work inside Hamilton.

V.

From the archive

On Accountability
Mr. Farrington's class has provided far more therapeutic benefit than FDC's mental health department ever has. He is so transparent about his own criminality. Nothing has been off the table.
M.L.M. · DIRECT class participant · Hamilton CI Main Unit
On Remorse
I have been attending his DIRECT class, which is a criminal psychology class where Mr. Farrington is forced to relive his crime every time he teaches. You can see the remorse and self-disgust of his crime.
R.N. · Fellow inmate · Hamilton SSCI
On the Evidence
He is exceptional, not a statistic. Look at what he does in here. Imagine what he will be able to do if he is free. People make mistakes — but look at what he has accomplished.
G.C. · Faith & Character Dorm · Hamilton SSCI
On Mentorship
I'm 61 years old and my first time in. With Gary's guidance and direction and as my mentor, I wouldn't have been able to turn my life around. It doesn't matter how much stress and pressure Gary has, he's always level-headed.
R.O. · 61, first-time incarcerated · Hamilton CI
On Daily Character
I've personally watched him walk around and give out food from his own locker to people that have nothing. And for that, he is a great man in my eyes.
D.J. · Hamilton SSCI
On Daily Discipline
Every morning at five o'clock you will see him without fail sitting down with a Bible open, no matter if it is a weekend or holiday, rain or sunshine. I can spot a God-fearing man out of a million people, and he is that one in a million.
J.L. · Fellow inmate · Hamilton SSCI
On Transformation
I had no intentions of being committed when I signed up for the Second Chance program. As one month turned into two, and two into three, I noticed a difference in the way I carry myself. Things in my life are getting better. I owe most of it to Gary.
T.C.A. · 3-year sentence · Hamilton SSCI
On Reach
Gracias a este hombre, mentes criminales como la mía han sido transformadas en algo mejor.“Thanks to this man, criminal minds like mine have been transformed into something better.”
L.M.N.D. · Hamilton CI · Originally written in Spanish
VI. · The Contradiction

Florida has placed Gary in a reentry facility.

Hamilton SSCI is a Level 3 short-sentence correctional institution. The men housed there are three to five years from release. The Florida Department of Corrections sends its short-sentenced men there because the environment is structured and the ministry is serious. They send them there, in other words, because of Gary and the Second Chance Academy he leads.

The state has made an operational judgment, year after year, that Gary's character is trustworthy enough, his influence is stabilizing enough, and his program is effective enough to place him at the center of men preparing to reenter society.

The state has decided Gary is rehabilitated. The law has not yet caught up.
VII.
The Fiscal Reality

What it costs Florida to keep Gary inside

$31K+
Per year, per inmate. Florida's current operating cost to incarcerate a single adult inmate.
$60K+
Per year, per elderly inmate. Healthcare costs roughly double the base figure as inmates age.
$3.3B
Florida's annual corrections budget. Less than $100M (~3%) offset by prison revenue generation.
VIII. · The Scale of the Problem
Zero

Pathways in Florida law for any life-sentenced person to demonstrate that their record should change what the state does next.

Florida is one of only seven states with no functional parole for life-sentenced inmates. Gary's case opens the door to a narrower conversation: not whether life sentences should hold, but whether the rare person whose record proves transformation should at least be heard.

35+

Other states where Gary would already be eligible for parole review.

By year 25 of his sentence, Gary would already be eligible for parole review in over 35 states — including Texas, California, New York, Georgia, Illinois, Michigan, and Pennsylvania. In Florida, there is no such pathway.

Seven predictors. Seven matches.One law that doesn't know how to listen.

Take Action→ Support This Work→